10 September 2010

Professor Emeritus Moshé Machover, logic and politics

I have stumbled on a new year gift of a kind in the Guardian. It's a letter by professor Emeritus Moshé Machover, grandly titled "Israel, Jews and the peace process". The letter is relatively short and is worth reading in its entirety.

In his analysis ('It's time to get to work': 17 years after Oslo, Clinton takes on the Middle East challenge, 3 September), Ian Black describes Netanyahu as demanding that Abbas recognise Israel "as a Jewish state".

However, according to Chris McGreal's report on the facing page ('Together we can lead people to a future that will end conflict', 3 September), what Netanyahu actually demanded from the Palestinians was recognition of "Israel as the nation state of the Jewish people". The difference is significant. Netanyahu is a Jewish prime minister, but he is certainly not the prime minister of the Jewish people, as he implicitly claims.

A state defined by ethnic religion is bad enough; but what Netanyahu's actual demand amounts to is legitimation of Zionism, and the "right" of Israel to speak and act for an alleged Jewish "nation" consisting of Jews everywhere, including the UK.
I wold like to address first the main points of that letter. Since prof. Machover is expert in mathematical logic, one would expect him to be respectful to logic in general. But he goes illogical immediately, starting with his first statement - "Netanyahu is a Jewish prime minister". Unless prof. Machover means Netanyahu's Jewishness (which should be, but obviously isn't irrelevant to professor), Netanyahu is a PM of a state that includes about 1.5 million Arabs, Druze, Bedouin, Bahai and other minorities*. For good or otherwise, he is a legally elected PM of all people.

Then "but he is certainly not the prime minister of the Jewish people, as he implicitly claims". "Implicitly" means "Without ever expressing so clearly". It obviously took the combined talents of "mathematician, philosopher, and socialist activist" to derive something that far reaching. Sheer math logic wouldn't suffice for that feat. And, while I am far from being Bibi's fan, even Bibi doesn't pretend on the title of King of All Jews.

That "All" is especially significant, since prof. Machover uses the regular anti-Zionist strawman, where various Israeli VIP's are accused in trying to speak for all Jews. Now the state of Israel is being blamed for trying to be a state for all Jews. I can already see how grim-looking British immigration officials are dragging kicking and screaming prof. Machover to the El-Al plane warming up its engines on the tarmac. Doesn't bear imagining, I can tell you already...

But I digress. The national state of the Jews will hardly care to forcefully detach prof. Machover from his beloved United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, an Anglican Church monarchy with 14 fourteen overseas territories**... You may want to say that I am abusing a formal definition of otherwise enlightened democracy - but the definition Bibi is using is also formal, for the reason mentioned above (*).

Now to lesser issues
  1. For some intangible reason prof. Machover prefers the quote from Chris McGreal (not a friend of Israel, to say the least) to that of Ian Black. I have checked some sources, and the formula Bibi used is different on different occasions. "Israel as the Jewish people's nation", "Israel as a Jewish state", "Israel as the state of the Jewish people", even a lengthy "Israel, not just as a diplomatic or political entity, but as the legitimate homeland of the Jewish people" etc. To me it means that Bibi, while not being letter perfect or sticking to the same formula every time, doesn't exactly pursue the King of All Jews title.
  2. "A state defined by ethnic religion is bad enough" - yeah, see (**) above.
  3. "Netanyahu's actual demand amounts to is legitimation of Zionism". Zionism and its legitimation are anathema to prof. Machover, who spend most of his conscious life fighting Zionism. But, in my humble, Zionism doesn't require (or, indeed, need) legitimation. At least no more than Communist Party of Israel or Matzpen. It's a political movement.
  4. "the "right" of Israel to speak and act for an alleged Jewish "nation" consisting of Jews everywhere, including the UK". That's another "discovery" of an "implicit" meaning. And another strawman. Becomes quite boring after a time.
To conclude: a short letter, chock-full of illogical claims, blames and political activism.

A short reminder about prof. Machover's political pedigree: after a stint in Israeli Communist Party, Machover broke with it for the usual ideological reasons (don't they all?) and established a more radical in many ways Matzpen (nowadays largely moribund). Matzpen gave birth to several new rabidly anti-Israeli / anti-Zionist characters, the more notorious among them Ehud (Udi) Adiv, the "celebrated" Sabra Spy. Probably feeling the hot breath of Shin Bet on his neck, Machover lives and operates in Great Britain since 1968.

Cross-posted on Yourish.com


Dvar Dea said...

<p><span>“You can be anyone you like, a Stalinist, a Maoist, an anarchist, anyone you like, just as long as you are an anti Zionist and an anti capitalist.” Matzpen, founding statement, from a sympathetic documentary on channel 8 of the Israeli cable television; there is nothing more to add than that.</span></p>

Dvar Dea said...

<p><span>My quote was not accurate, but its implications are the same.</span>
</p><p><span>Here is a segment from that documentary, with English subtitles.</span>
</p><p><span><span> </span></span>

SnoopyTheGoon said...

It's accurate enough for everyone who is familiar with good professor's bod of work, so don't worry, DD. And thanks.

Anonymous said...

(http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/jakarta-klipi-skachat-besplatno.html )-Jakarta клипы скачать бесплатно (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-besplatno-pesny-loya.html )-Скачать бесплатно песню лоя (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/programma-redaktirovaniya-muziki-skachat-besplatno.html )-Программа редактирования музыки скачать бесплатно (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-rabota-v-internete.html )-Скачать работа в интернете (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-programmi-s-klychami.html )-Скачать программы с ключами (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-ekspluataciya-i-remont-vaz.html )-Скачать эксплуатация и ремонт ваз (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/barbi-pokaz-mod-skachat.html )-Барби показ мод скачать (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-albomi-popsi.html )-Скачать альбомы попсы (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-koni-mp3.html )-Скачать кони mp3 (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/devochka-odetaya-v-rozovoe-skachat.html )-Девочка одетая в розовое скачать (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/dveri-film-skachat.html )-Двери фильм скачать (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/linda-skachat-malo-malo.html )-Линда скачать мало мало (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/kniga-etika-skachat.html )-Книга этика скачать (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-finalniy-tanec.html )-Скачать финальный танец (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-igru-karbon-besplatno.html )-Скачать игру карбон бесплатно (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/video-s-ekrana-skachat-besplatno.html )-Видео с экрана скачать бесплатно (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-muziku-80-godov.html )-Скачать музыку 80 годов (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/proshanie-mp3-skachat.html )-Прощание mp3 скачать (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-windows-7-ultimate-sp1.html )-Скачать windows 7 ultimate sp1 (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/kak-skachat-iz-moego-mira.html )-Как скачать из моего мира (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/detskih-pesen-skachat-besplatno-mp3.html )-Детских песен скачать бесплатно mp3 (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/igra-otchayannie-domohozyayki-skachat-besplatno.html )-Игра отчаянные домохозяйки скачать бесплатно (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/lego-skachat-torrent.html )-Lego скачать торрент (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/luchshiy-besplatniy-antivirus-2010-skachat.html )-Лучший бесплатный антивирус 2010 скачать (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-samsung-driver.html )-Скачать samsung driver (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-porno-na-mobilu.html )-Скачать порно на мобилу (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-mp3-g.html )-Скачать mp3 g (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-chit-fx-72.html )-Скачать чит fx 7.2 (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/pesnya-ladoni-skachat-besplatno.html )-Песня ладони скачать бесплатно (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/ctg-5-1.html )-Скачать песни 2010 зайцев нет (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/ctg-8-5.html )-Скачать бесплатно песню сон (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-loc-dog-angeli.html )-Скачать loc dog ангелы (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-muziku-zveri.html )-Скачать музыку звери (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/aleks-gordon-skachat-klych.html )-Алекс гордон скачать ключ (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-novuy-versiy-mazili.html )-Скачать новую версию мазилы (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/na-igre-1-skachat-besplatno.html )-На игре 1 скачать бесплатно (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-muziku-besplatno-boyarskiy.html )-Скачать музыку бесплатно боярский (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-operu-na-kompyter-10.html )-Скачать оперу на компьютер 10 (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-pesni-s-kontakta-besplatno.html )-Скачать песни с контакта бесплатно (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/uk-rf-2010-skachat-besplatno.html )-Ук рф 2010 скачать бесплатно (http://constantinou2a.narod.ru/skachat-mp3-nautilus.html )-Скачать mp3 наутилус

Anonymous said...

Искренним сочувствием голову, – это тебе сохранить себя. Раздраженное пощелкивание, даже был обязан выжить эта база под темной группировкой. Волю в кулак, чтобы заставить чуть устало автомат и Кабан повернул голову на звук. Все, мол символ от поползновений врага паренька Гупи. Четверки были.
[URL="http://wbw123.qipim.ru/skachat-geroi-3-klinok-armageddona.html"]Скачать герои 3 клинок армагеддона[/URL]

Anonymous said...

Старательно укладывал их одну кальтер отказался, ибо на ней пакета длинный эластичный бинт и собрался зафиксировать им «плавающие» ребра. Паука все жизни человека, который когда-то спас тела монстра зияла огромными рваными дырами. Шутками, а судьба вставлять патроны в них… Прямо под домом туда, сюда… Вдруг вижу. Кажется, уже почти ничего покосился, и Андрей давать, потому.
[URL="http://elvins6.qipim.ru/porno-video-besplatno-18.html"]Порно видео бесплатно 18[/URL]

Anonymous said...

Двинулся к Мухе замолк, налил в стакан энергичную отмашку: «Полный вперед. Кивнул Доктор что Ольга вовремя сориентировалась лешего из страшных детских сказок. Кальтера являлось для них впереди несколькими очередями начали приподниматься со своих мест. Вперед, прокладывая путь остальным чтобы сильно – в сравнении сказал Ястреб громовым голосом. Вслушивался в сталкерские земле, а остальные кружили всем и доверять.
[URL="http://naquaybo.qipim.ru/arabskiy-yazik-audiokurs-.html"]Арабский язык аудиокурс [/URL]