07 April 2010

Judith Butler and the hazards of higher learning

To my shame, I was ignorant of professor Butler's existence, so you will have to bear with me through some quotes from her Wiki bio:

Judith Butler (born 24 February 1956) is an American post-structuralist philosopher, who has contributed to the fields of feminism, queer theory, political philosophy, and ethics. She is currently the Maxine Elliott professor in the Rhetoric and Comparative Literature departments at the University of California, Berkeley.
I confess to understanding most words in the above, if not some of the constructs ("queer theory"?). In any case, it's clear that we are looking at an extraordinary gifted person, and the (partial) list of honors and awards only strengthens this impression:
  • 2008: Andrew W. Mellon Foundation Distinguished Achievement Award, University of California, Berkeley
  • 2007: Elected a Member of the American Philosophical Society
  • 2004: Brudner Prize, Yale University
  • 2001: Rockefeller Fellowship
  • 1999: Guggenheim Fellowship
One should be honored to receive his measure of oxygen from the same atmosphere, I would say. And be happy that our kids' brains and futures are being molded by such capable hands.

Then one encounters a quote from the professor's body of work:
Yes, understanding Hamas, Hezbollah as social movements that are progressive, that are on the Left, that are part of a global Left, is extremely important.
And one starts wondering. Not about the possible fate of the esteemed professor (awards and honors included), would the esteemed professor have been born in one of the Hezbollah enclaves. And not really about the "progressive social movements". And not even about the "global Left".

It's our kids that I am concerned about, you see...

Via Contested Terrain.

14 comments:

Pisa said...

The progressive jihad of the global left. Goal no. 1: destroy. Tools: once bright young people brainwashed into obedience. Marx et Allah ltd.<span> </span>  

jams o donnell said...

Pah,  Hamas and Hezbollah progressives? Bullhit! or at least they are progressives in the same way that the North Koreans are... It is the curse of the leftist to hate most of one's fellow leftists as much ore even more than the Right. This isn't a point of dogma but simply having no time for ignorant shit stains like this

SnoopyTheGoon said...

That too.

Katie said...

The left are like lemmings.  Follow the leader unto death, regardless if that leader will kill us all.

Noga said...

Martha Nussbaum had a great quarrel with Butler when she criticized her style and type of engagement in an article entitled:

"THe professor of parody"

http://www.arlindo-correia.com/100702.html

I once had to read "Gender Trouble". I thought the fault of not understanding was me not being knowledgeable or sophisticated enough to figure out what she was saying. A bewildering experience.

Dick Stanley said...

I'm surprised she's not one of Obamalot's czars. She's got the rhetoric down cold.

Dick Stanley said...

Bats are cool, though.

Dick Stanley said...

Post-structuralist? That explains it. Her philosophy has no structure, making her vulnerable to every passing fad, such as romanticising terrorists.

Sergio said...

Let's be honest: she is a "professor" of pseudo-science, which already took a stronghold in the universities, mainly in the humanities and social science depts. This is the fruit of the "teachings" of such luminaries as Heidegger, Lacan, Derrida, the counterculture, may 68' left -wing nonsense.  Postmodernism, moral relativism, psychoanalysis, this is the real treason of
the clerks, it ever there was one.

David All said...

Well whatever nonsense she says, it sure beats working for a living. Now if only I could find a way into that racket as well.  

SnoopyTheGoon said...

Thanks Noga, I have enjoyed the squabble. The sharks of science indeed...

SnoopyTheGoon said...

I wish it were a mere passing fad.

SnoopyTheGoon said...

Treason of clerks is a good one, Sergio, I appreciate it!

And yes, the so called "postmodernism" bunch of "sciences" is a pathetic revolt of nobodies.

SnoopyTheGoon said...

I am afraid, David, that the competition for these positions is too stiff. Ours is to envy only...